Besides Tramontina, the Martha Stewart Collection is more attainable for most budgets. When properly cared for cast iron cookware can be passed down across generations. We spent 10 hours compiling owner feedback and product information on the Tramontina Enameled Cast Iron Dutch Oven, and comparing this product with other leading brands. David is the creator of Kitchen Ambition, and has been cooking seriously for about 10 years. Owners noted Tramontina is also easy to clean. Click here to check current pricing and see more product specs. While it’s similar to other gourmet Dutch ovens, the Staub version has a matte black enameled interior that won’t show stains or scratches as easily as competitor’s white enameled interiors. These ridges collect steam and allow condensed liquid to drip back down evenly across the food, rather than only at the edges of the lid. When you make a purchase through links on this page, we may earn a commission. Most damage we analyzed occured to the dish interior. For Roasting Juicy Meats: Crock-Pot Artisan Braiser with Self-Basting Lid. A stainless steel Dutch oven is less common than cast iron versions but offers some advantages that are worth considering. to help you make better choices for life’s big moments and the everyday ones in between. While these materials may be lighter, occasionally cheaper, and more responsive to changes in temperature, they don’t serve the traditional purpose of a dutch oven to seamlessly hold a consistent and high temperature for long periods of time. Specifically this was an issue when the shape of meat the cut of meat was wider than the dish. This splurge-worthy piece of cookware is a must-have item for anyone that loves the low and slow cooking method of Dutch ovens or demands a versatile and durable pot that goes from stove to oven. This can be especially noticeable across the pan interior, which generates the most contact with food, but is also worth considering if you’re considering the white exterior color option. Nonstick for Quick Clean-Up: Calphalon Classic Nonstick Covered Dutch Oven, 7 Qt. A big concern with enamel Dutch ovens is chipping of the protective enamel coating. Incremental wear over a 3-5 year window seems to be a feature of this product, while the more abrupt or significant damage typically resulted from handling. Each model is constructed of thick enameled cast iron for even heat distribution and retention. You will get digital access to reviews and ratings for over 8,500 products and services For example, we use a Griswold frying pan set in our kitchen that is nearly 100 years old. These types differ in their features and benefits and may not offer the purest Dutch oven cooking experience, but can be quick to clean-up and less time-consuming to maintain. If you buy a defective Tramontina product, you can contact the manufacturer through a form here on their website. © 2020 Forbes Media LLC. They make an exceptionally attractive and durable product, but you’ll probably pay 3-4x more for a similarly sized dutch oven to those offered by Tramontina. In addition, a stainless steel Dutch oven will heat up more quickly than cast iron versions. account information here. A note for your safety, use an oven mitt when cooking with this dish. The best dutch ovens are made from strong, durable cast iron materials that retain heat and distribute it evenly throughout the dish. This type of Dutch oven is generally more shallow and features a lid specially designed for self-basting. Originally from the American South, the spirit of bringing people together fueled his passion for cooking. A Basic Version without a Big Spend: AmazonBasics Covered Dutch Oven, 6 Qt. While a dutch oven is an incredibly versatile dish, it’s not a daily-use item for most people. Target Coupons | 50% Off In November 2020 | Forbes, EY & Citi On The Importance Of Resilience And Innovation, Impact 50: Investors Seeking Profit — And Pushing For Change, Michigan Economic Development Corporation BrandVoice. Reviewers point that there is plenty of room inside for chickens, roasts and more and that it cooks evenly on both the stovetop and in the oven. Learn More. Make no mistake about it, investing in a Dutch oven from Le Creuset will set you back $200 or $300, but loyalists to the brand emphasize the superior durability and long-lasting value of this top-rated Dutch oven. A Must-Have for Foodies: Staub Cast-Iron Round Dutch Oven, 7 Qt. This dutch oven will deliver heat slowly to tenderize meats, poultry and vegetables and comes in a vibrant, gradated porcelain enamel exterior finish offering an elegant kitchen to … In addition, cooks find that the ever-so-slightly textured quartz enamel finish develops a seasoned quality and contributes to better browning. It is a great place to start, and if you use it heavily over the next several years then you might consider upgrading on the next purchase. In our view, the potential for improved durability might not be worth the risk of buying a defective Martha Stewart product. Le Creuset cookware comes in a rainbow of hues, and each year the company releases a new color, enticing you to add to your collection. While cast iron will oxidize and rust if exposed to the elements, the primary durability issue for enameled dutch ovens is actually the enamel coating. The Dutch Oven Casserole comes with a heavy enameled cast iron lid with stainless steel knob. Given Stewart’s recent manufacturing recalls, and that most buying options are available only through Macy’s brick-and-mortar stores, Tramontina may be a safer option for an affordable dutch oven. Less durable than premium brands, affordable for … A covered dutch oven is among the most versatile of modern cookware tools. Available in a handful of attractive color choices and a capacity of 6 quarts (perfect for family dinners or recipes with leftovers), this is a solid piece of cookware that holds its own against more prestigious French brands. Opinions expressed by Forbes Contributors are their own. Some brands offer a dutch oven product that has been constructed of alternative materials, like clad stainless steel or aluminum. It’s ideal for browning meats before roasting them in the oven, preparing homemade soups with rich flavors or baking no-knead bread in a super-hot oven. By using this site, you accept our use of cookies. Some owners complained about slow responsiveness from the brand to their inquiries. All Rights Reserved, This is a BETA experience. Count on this basic Dutch oven for low and slow cooking and you won’t be disappointed. The Tramontina Gourmet Enameled Cast Iron Dutch Oven may look heavy duty, but it was actually among the lightest of the casserole dishes in our test. We like to invest heavily in the most frequently used items for our kitchen, and pick more affordable options for lesser used dishes. Some dutch ovens don’t come pre-seasoned, so you’ll have to season them yourself before you can start cooking. When shopping for a Dutch oven, you’re likely to encounter the well-known French brands that offer handmade and heirloom-quality cookware. While the top-trending Dutch ovens are typically brightly colored enamel versions that are almost too pretty to stash away in a cabinet, don’t overlook the rather plain-looking, non-enamel cast iron Dutch oven. If you drop your dutch oven and break or chip it, you can’t request a new one. Most dutch ovens are sized between 3-5 quarts, but you can find them as small as ¼ quart and occasionally as large as 9 quarts. However, a stainless steel version, like the Tramontina Gourmet Prima Dutch Oven, is a durable option that eliminates concerns over chipping and adds the bonus of being dishwasher-safe. Because the enamel is somewhat porous, it is also likely that surfaces will collect stains when exposed to dark acidic foods like tomatoes at high temperatures. While the Staub Dutch oven is a major investment upwards of $300 for a 7-quart version, it’s sure to last for a lifetime of gourmet cooking. There were also a handful of cases where an owner highlighted chips or cracks in the enamel that occurred during use. Le Creuset is a high-quality brand that’s loved and revered by chefs around the world. With a single dish you can roast, stew, sear, bake or braise. Perhaps the most recognizable name in the world of Dutch ovens is French stoneware maker, Le Creuset. Staub is also a very reputable maker. 97 - $61.00 $ 61 . Top Option to Last a Lifetime: Le Creuset Round Dutch Oven. Some owners noted that the 5.5-Qt round dutch oven is slightly narrower and taller than other dutch ovens of the same volume. Oven-safe up to 500 degrees, fine French cookware is made to take the heat. This can become a safety hazard if you aren’t prepared with the right gear. Many owners who provided a review of their experience with this product noted that the interior enamel began to wear off after a few years of use. This white color reflects light more effectively than raw cast iron and therefore provides a helpful visual contrast.